Best Cookie Sheet Reviews

In a rush? Don’t have time to read detailed information about the best cookie sheet? We have you covered. This short paragraph should offer sufficient information for you to make a smart choice. Baking sheets are a must have in any kitchen, as they aid a great deal with reducing cooking times and helping cookies maintain their delicious crispiness with minimum effort from your part. We have run a lot of research on the best cookie sheets you can find right now and based on the consumers’ feedback we gathered and other considerations like sales figures and ratings, we identified two brands you should try for honing your skills as a home based cook. The Vollrath 68085 is the cookie sheet of choice for many users, because it helps baking faster and better, while you do not have to do anything more than follow the instructions. Considered by many to be the best insulated cookie sheet, this one is made of heavy duty aluminum that insures proper and even heating. Available in two finish options, natural aluminum and premium non-stick coating, this cookie sheet will ensure the success of your cooking each and every time. In case the Vollrath 68085 is out of stock, you can always pick the T-fal 84756 AirBake Natural as a great alternative. Made of 100% high quality aluminum, this cookie sheet does not rust and can be kept in your pantry for up to 10 years.



Comparison table:


ProductMaterialDimensionsPriceOur ratingBest Price on:
Vollrath 68085 Cookie Sheet
Best Cookie Sheet Reviews
Heavy-gauge 3004 aluminum17 x 14$$$$A+Amazon
T-fal 84756 Airbake Cookie Sheet Set
Aluminum16 x 14$$$AAmazon
Farberware Nonstick Bakeware Cookie Pan
Carbon steel9 x 13
10 x 15
11 x 17
Nordic Ware Naturals Sheet Baking Pan
Aluminum18 x 13$$BAmazon
Good Cook Cookie Sheet Set
Steel9 x 13
10 x 15
11 x 16 1/2



Buying guide


You may feel tempted to think that cookie sheets are all the same, since the purpose they serve is so mundane. However, if you really care about the success of your baking, and you want your baked goods to be the best, you should learn how to tell different types of cookie sheets apart and which one to use given the recipes you are trying to cook. This buying guide will help you identify the best baking sheets for your needs, so that you can always excel in the kitchen.1.Vollrath 68085


There are many different types of cookie sheets on the market, even if that may not be noticeable at first glance. For instance, cookie sheets are made of different materials, metal being the most common. Stainless steel cookie sheets, for instance, are considered among the best, because they distribute the heat evenly and they are excellent for baking a wide range of cookies and other baked goods. Aluminum, tin and aluminized steel are other common metals used for cookie sheets.

Another aspect that differentiates various types of cookie sheets is their color. Lighter colored cookie sheets will help you obtain a more even baking, while darker sheets will cause them to overbrown.

Next thing on your list should be whether you should get the non-stick kind. The obvious advantage is that non-stick cookie sheets help you maintain your cookies grease free and lower the intake of fat.

Insulated cookie sheets are another type you can buy from the market. They are ideal for using with ovens that tend to overbrown and dry your cookies. By capturing the moisture and heat inside, the cookie sheets will prevent such mishaps and you will be able to enjoy perfect cookies each and every time.




Cookie sheets come in many different sizes. Depending on the recipe you want to make, you may need some that are larger or some that are smaller. The best advice is to get a few sizes, so you can have them available when you want to bake. Here is a small tip for purchasing the right size: when you place the baking sheet over the oven rack, make sure that there are at least two inches of space left on all sides, as they are required for the air to circulate.




Thickness is another consideration to keep in mind when you are shopping for the best cookie sheets for baking. The thin kind is the variety you can find in any store. People prefer them because they are really cheap, but there are certain downsides to them. For starters, thin cookie sheets have a tendency to warp and modify their shape, flinging your cookies around in the oven. When the cookie sheets are too thin, you may get really overbrowned cookies, or cookies that are too dry. While there may be recipes out there that require your cookies to be dryer, this is not always the case, so the usefulness for such baking sheets is reduced.

Even if you have to spend a bit extra, we recommend getting thicker sheets. Professional cooks use something called jelly roll pans, which are basically half sheet pans. These can be found in stores specialized in selling kitchenware, as well as those selling restaurant supplies. You will be able to tell them apart from the rest, since they are wider and shorter than thin baking sheets.

When you are using thick baking sheets, your cookies will take longer to brown and they will not dry easily. However, you should keep in mind that these top rated cookie sheets will not work that well if you want to make cookies really fast, and have them out of the oven within minutes.2.T-fal 84756 Airbake

Rimmed or rimless?

The last important aspect to consider when buying cookie sheets is whether you should get the rimmed or the rimless variety. In case you want to obtain smooth delicate cookies, the best advice is to go for rimless cookie sheets. This is important, because you will want to manipulate your spatula with ease, and get the cookies out of the sheet without anything hindering you in the process.

When to buy rimmed cookie sheets, then? For any kind of roasting, these are great because they do not allow unwanted spills to make a mess inside your oven. The cookies will not slide from the sheets and you will be able to take them out, without any accidents waiting to happen at the horizon. As with thickness, size and other aspects, having sheets of all varieties will help you bake anything you want, with great results.



Top Cookie Sheets in 2018


Even baking experts themselves consult the best cookie sheet reviews to find the perfect baking solutions for their specific needs. A cookie sheet has a curved edge on one or two sides. There are also brands with four rimmed edges. These curved edges serve as handles as well as allow air and heat to circulate evenly over the cookies while baking. Preferably, a cookie sheet has heavy aluminum or stainless steel material, as an extremely thin material can cause the pan to warp or the dough to undergo uneven spreading or cooking. After having tried about over twenty cookie sheets, I have concluded that these five brands are the perfect cookie baking solutions.



Vollrath 68085


Best Cookie Sheet ReviewsFeatured in Cooks Illustrated Magazine, the Vollrath 68085 Aluminum Cookie Sheet truly deserves a space in the best cookie sheet reviews. It has a natural finish and measures 17 7/8 inches x 14inches. It is of heavy gauge aluminum construction, which ensures years and years of use. The heavy-duty aluminum material also ensures even and rapid cooking at all times. Thanks to its natural matte finish, the Vollrath 68065 enables easy release of baked goodies and is easy to clean. This cookie sheet has two curved sides so handling is made easy.



Click here to buy from!




T-fal 84756 Airbake


Made of 100% aluminum, the T-fal 84756 Airbake Cookie Sheet Set is also protected against rusting and corrosion, a quality that makes it the best cookie sheet in 2018. The T-Fal cookie sheet is composed of two pieces that enlarge your baking collection handsomely. The two pans are guaranteedagainst burning, as they allow consistent baking on all sides. Each piece is large and insulated, dishwasher safe and really functional. They are made using patented Micro-Dome technology, which means you need up to 15% less time to bake as compared to conventional bakeware.



Buy from Amazon for ($21.99)




Farberware Nonstick Bakeware Cookie Pan


This set has three cookie pans in all: one measuring 11” x 17”; another pan measuring 9” x 13”; and a third cookie pan measuring 10” x 15”. The bakeware set components are all of premium non-stick material, which makes each of them a delight to use and a breeze to clean. From one of the most reputable bakeware brands come cookie sheets with nonstick surfaces on the inside and out, which makes them the supreme choice in many top rated cookie sheet reviews everywhere. The light gray color lets you accurately assess the degree of browning in your baked goodies.



Click to see the price on Amazon!




Nordic Ware Naturals Sheet Baking Pan


What has made the Nordic Ware Naturals Sheet Baking Pan the best cookie sheet in 2018 is the half-sheet aluminum composition that it carries. With this material, the Nordic Ware baking pan is guaranteed to be rust-resistant for a long time. Aside from its durability, this baking pan’s aluminum construction also guarantees superior heat conductivity that makes baked products rise really nicely during the baking process. The reinforced coated rim is protected from warping. You just need to wash the pan with your hands, making for easy clean-up after use.



Buy from Amazon for ($9.97)




Good Cook Cookie Sheet Set


This 3-piece cookie sheet set from Good Cook has three units of bakeware that are all heavy duty. With a small, medium and large cookie sheet each, you will always have the right size of pan to use for your baking requirements. Every rectangular cookie pan in this set is dishwasher safe. Use them to make your favorite cookies, which come out perfect every time. Cookies just slide off easily when they’re taken out of the oven. And because they’re non-stick, you don’t have to do heavy soaking and scrubbing after use.



Buy from Amazon for ($18.79)